VEHICLE HISTORY REPORT COMPARISON, 2027

Carfax vs. AutoCheck vs. VinPassed

Carfax, AutoCheck, VinAudit, Bumper, and EpicVIN all show you what happened to a car. VinPassed shows you what it means, and what it is likely to cost you.

Get a VinPassed Report

The short version: Carfax ($49.99) has the deepest service records and the only buyback guarantee. AutoCheck ($29.99) is the value pick for checking several cars. VinAudit ($9.99) is the cheapest single report in this table. VinPassed ($30) includes the same core history (title, accidents, odometer, theft) and adds repair cost estimates, upcoming maintenance, known model problems, and, on auction cars, the photos and price from before the dealer bought it.

By the VinPassed Editorial Team· Pricing and features verified October 2026How we verified this

How do Carfax, AutoCheck and VinPassed compare on price and features?

← Scroll to compare →

FEATURE
VinPassed
$30
Carfax
$49.99
AutoCheck
$29.99
VinAudit
$9.99
Bumper
$27.99/mo
EpicVIN
$24.99
PRICING
Single report price
What you pay for one report
$30$49.99$29.99$9.99$27.99/mo$24.99
No subscription required
Pay once, keep forever, no recurring charges
✅✅✅✅❌✅
Multi-report package
Lowest per-report price when you buy more than one
5 for $90 ($18/ea)4 for $119.99 ($30/ea)5 for $59.99 ($12/ea)10 for $29.99 ($3/ea)Subscription16 for $86 ($5.40/ea)
Basic title & theft check
Low-cost check of title status and theft records only, not a full report
$5❌❌~❌❌
Buyback guarantee
Vehicle repurchase if a severe DMV title brand was missed on the report, Carfax only
❌✅❌❌❌❌
LOOKING BACK: EVERY REPORT DOES THIS
Title history & brands
Salvage, flood, lemon law, rebuilt, junk titles
✅✅✅✅✅✅
Accident & damage records
Reported collisions, airbag deployment, severity
✅✅✅~✅✅
Ownership history
Number of previous owners, state registrations
✅✅✅✅✅✅
Odometer readings
Mileage history to detect rollback fraud
✅✅✅✅✅✅
Service & maintenance records
Dealer and shop-reported service history
✅✅~~~~
Recall information
Open and resolved manufacturer safety recalls
✅✅✅✅✅✅
Stolen vehicle check
National theft database verification
✅✅✅✅✅✅
LOOKING FORWARD: WHAT IT WILL COST YOU
📊 12 market valuations
Private party, dealer retail, trade-in, and more, every number you need
✅~❌~~❌
🔧 Repair cost estimates
What it'll cost to fix reported damage, before you commit to buying
✅❌❌❌❌❌
📋 Upcoming maintenance schedule
What service is due based on mileage, so you know what you're inheriting
✅~❌❌~❌
⚠️ Known model problems (TSBs)
Technical Service Bulletins, manufacturer-acknowledged issues for this specific model
✅❌❌❌❌❌
🤖 AI risk analysis
Everything synthesized into plain-language risk assessment and buyer recommendation
✅❌❌❌❌❌
🌐 Reports in 10 languages
AI analysis available in English, Spanish, Chinese, Vietnamese, Tagalog, Portuguese, French, Arabic, Korean, Russian
✅❌❌❌❌❌
📸 Auction photos (when available)
Bonus when the car has auction history: pre-sale condition photos from before cleaning and detailing. Not every vehicle goes through auction, so this isn't on every report.
~❌~❌❌❌
💰 Dealer purchase price (when available)
Bonus when auction data exists: what the dealer paid, so you can negotiate on equal footing. Only available for vehicles with auction history.
~❌❌❌❌❌
Get startedGet ReportVisit siteVisit siteVisit siteVisit siteVisit site
✅Included
~Limited / varies by VIN
❌Not included

Every provider on this list tells you what happened to the car.

VinPassed also shows what it is likely to cost you.

Carfax and AutoCheck are history reports, built to show you where a car has been. VinPassed looks the other direction as well: what it may cost to own, what may be about to need repair, and what the dealer paid before it hit the lot.

See VinPassed Pricing

How we verified this comparison

Every feature claim in the table above is a claim about what each report contains, and every provider publishes an official sample report, so you can check each one yourself. We compared the published samples section by section, re-verified pricing on each provider's site in October 2026, and drew on independent same-VIN testing by Edmunds for coverage differences between Carfax and AutoCheck. VinPassed's own sample reports for three real vehicles are public on our sample report page.

One limitation: published samples prove what each report format includes, not how much data each provider finds on a given car. Record coverage varies by VIN for every provider, including us. For coverage, pair any report with an independent pre-purchase inspection.

Carfax vs AutoCheck vs VinPassed: your questions answered

How is VinPassed different from Carfax and AutoCheck?

Carfax and AutoCheck are backward-looking history reports: they show you title records, reported accidents, ownership changes, and odometer readings, what already happened to the car. VinPassed includes that same history, then adds a forward-looking layer no history report offers: repair cost estimates for reported damage, the upcoming maintenance schedule based on mileage, known model problems (Technical Service Bulletins), 12 market valuations, and, when the vehicle has auction history, pre-sale auction photos and the price the dealer paid. Everything is synthesized into a plain-language AI risk assessment. In short: Carfax and AutoCheck tell you where the car has been; VinPassed also tells you what owning it is likely to cost.

What does a Carfax report cost in 2027?

A single Carfax report costs $49.99 as of October 2026, the highest single-report price in this comparison. AutoCheck is $29.99, VinPassed $30, EpicVIN $24.99 and VinAudit $9.99. Carfax also sells 2 reports for $69.99 and 4 for $119.99, about $30 each.

See every Carfax package price and why it costs more

Is AutoCheck as good as Carfax?

In Edmunds testing, Carfax surfaced records AutoCheck missed: on one test Porsche it showed 15 service records to AutoCheck's 3. AutoCheck is about $20 cheaper per report, and its five-report pack works out to roughly $12 a report. For one high-stakes purchase, Carfax's deeper records can justify the premium. For screening several cars, AutoCheck's pack pricing is hard to beat.

Read the full Carfax vs AutoCheck comparison

Is a $9.99 VinAudit report good enough?

For basic verification, yes, VinAudit is the cheapest single report in this comparison. It is an approved NMVTIS data provider, so its $9.99 report covers title records and brands (salvage, flood, junk), odometer readings, theft records, liens, and sale history. What it lacks is depth and analysis: service records are thin, accident detail is limited, and there are no repair estimates, no maintenance schedule, no Technical Service Bulletins, no auction photos, and no dealer purchase price. If all you need is a title and theft check, VinPassed offers a $5 basic check covering exactly that. If you are about to spend thousands on the car itself, the gap between a $9.99 records dump and a full report with cost analysis is usually worth the difference.

What is the Carfax Buyback Guarantee, and does anyone else offer it?

Only Carfax offers it, and it counts in Carfax's favor. If a DMV-reported severe title brand (salvage, junk, flood and similar) existed when the report was run but wasn't on it, Carfax may buy the vehicle back. The guarantee is narrow: it doesn't cover missed accidents, missed service records or undisclosed damage, and claims need documentation. No other provider on this page, including VinPassed, offers one.

Is Carfax worth it? When the guarantee matters

What will no vehicle history report show you?

No provider, not VinPassed, not Carfax, not anyone, can show events that were never reported. An accident settled in cash without an insurance claim or police report will not appear on any history report. Maintenance done by the owner in their driveway leaves no record. Damage repaired at an independent shop that does not report data is invisible. This is why every report on this page, ours included, should be paired with a pre-purchase inspection by an independent mechanic. A history report tells you what the paper trail says; an inspection tells you what the car itself says. Serious buyers use both.

Which report is best for a car that went through auction?

Auction history is where reports differ most, and what happened there is often the most revealing part of the record. AutoCheck sources data from the two largest U.S. auctions and flags auction events. VinPassed goes further when auction records exist: it retrieves pre-sale condition photos taken before the car was cleaned and detailed, showing damage as it actually looked, and the price the dealer paid at auction, which tells you exactly how much negotiating room exists. Neither is available on every vehicle (the car must have passed through a reporting auction), which is why the table marks these features as varying by VIN.

Pricing and features current as of October 2026, from each provider's own checkout or pricing page. EpicVIN lists its single report at $24.99 with $49.99 shown crossed out. Bumper is $27.99 a month. AutoCheck's single report includes 21 days of data updates. Competitor features based on publicly available information and may vary by VIN. "~" indicates the feature is partially available or varies by vehicle. Auction photo availability and dealer cost data depend on whether the vehicle passed through a reporting auction. VinPassed is not affiliated with Carfax, AutoCheck, VinAudit, Bumper, or EpicVIN.